$15 off orders of $100+ before October 31. Use code EARLYBIRD.
Thanksgiving Pie Shop
It's the best season of all!
Whole pies baked from scratch for your holiday table, plus fried chicken, sides and biscuits for the party.
Pickup or delivery · Oct 12 – Nov 25
The best holidays have pie
Follow us @piesnthighs for limited archival pie drops to celebrate our 20th anniversary.
Order ahead for pickup or delivery from Williamsburg or Park Slope!
Pies & Catering
Apple Pie, Whole
Serves 6-8 Classic Granny Smith apple pie with gooey cinnamon filling and an all butter crust.
$45.00
Order Now
Banana Cream, Whole Pie
Serves 6-8 Creamy, banana pudding filling topped with Nilla wafers and whipped topping, in a Nilla wafer crust.
$45.00
Order Now
Bourbon Pecan, Whole Pie
Serves 6-8 Organic pecans filling with a hit of bourbon and a bit of dark chocolate.
$45.00
Order Now
Sour Cherry & Pear Pie, Whole
Serves 6-8 Sour cherries & pears with a buttery crumble topping.
$45.00
Order Now
Sweet Potato Pie, Whole
Roasted sweet potato chess pie with buttermilk and citrus in an all-butter crust. Only 100 available. When they’re gone, they’re gone.
$45.00
Order Now
Fried Chicken & Classic Sides Package
Serves 15-20 Includes 40 pieces of fried chicken, 1 tray of arugula salad, your choice of 2 sides, 20 buttermilk biscuits, honey butter, and hot sauce.
$300.00
Order Now
Fried Chicken Tray
Serves 12-15 Includes 24-piece tray of crispy, golden perfection. Our signature buttermilk-brined chicken, hand-breaded and fried to order.
$82.00
Order Now
Tenders Tray
Serves 12-15 Includes 24-piece tray of crispy, hand breaded Chicken Tenders. Our signature brined chicken tender, fried to perfection, served with our homemade Delight Sauce. Antibiotic & Hormone Free.
$90.00
Order Now
"New" Roast Chicken Tray
Serves 12- Includes 12- 1/4 roast chicken pieces, that's 3-whole chickens. This is our new dry brined, roasted to golden perfection recipe. Antibiotic & Hormone Free.
$82.00
Order Now
Chicken & Waffles Tray
Serves 12-15 Includes 24 pieces of fried chicken and 24 homemade waffles. Served with maple syrup, fruit compote, and cinnamon butter.
$175.00
Order Now
Cornmeal Fried Catfish Tray
Serves 10-20 Crispy cornmeal crusted catfish filets with tartar sauce and lemon wedges. Small tray contains 12 pcs; large tray contains 24 pcs.
$70.00+
Order Now
Chicken Biscuit Sandwich
Serves 12 Preassembled & individually wrapped. Comes with extra hot sauce & butter on the side.
$110.00
Order Now
Veggie Chik’n Biscuit Sandwich
Serves 12 Preassembled & individually wrapped. Includes plant-based patties, biscuits, honey butter, and hot sauce.
$110.00
Order Now
Egg & Cheese Biscuit "Banjo"
Serves 12 Preassembled & individually wrapped breakfast sandwich on our fresh baked, homemade biscuit. Includes egg, American cheese on biscuit.
$96.00
Order Now
Egg & Cheese + Bacon Biscuit "Banjo"
Serves 12 Preassembled & individually wrapped breakfast sandwich on our fresh baked, homemade biscuit. Includes egg, American cheese + bacon on biscuit.
$115.00
Order Now
Big Salad Tray
Serves 10-12 Iceberg lettuce, Avocado, black-eyed peas, hard boiled egg, beets, radishes, carrots & alfalfa sprouts. Includes your choice of homemade ranch or cilantro lime dressings.
$65.00
Order Now
Dozen Biscuits with Honey Butter
Our famous buttermilk biscuits. Comes with honey butter. 12 pcs.
$45.00
Order Now
Waffle Tray
Serves 10-20 Your choice of 12-24 homemade waffles. Served with maple syrup, fruit compote, and cinnamon butter.
$45.00+
Order Now
Half Dozen Toffee Pecan Donuts
Made fresh daily, with brown sugar toffee and ground organic pecans.
$25.00
Order Now
Half Dozen Chocolate Cake Donuts
Made fresh daily, our chocolate cake donut is perfect!
$22.00
Order Now
Half Dozen Glazed Donuts
Made fresh daily, our award winning traditional glazed donut.
$22.00
Order Now
Dozen Fresh Baked Cookies
Made fresh daily. Choose from chocolate chip, spicy molasses. 12 pcs.
$33.00
Order Now